Visit Us in Petoskey Michigan - 8591 Horton Bay Road
Visit Us in Petoskey Michigan - 8591 Horton Bay Road
.jpg/:/rs=w:600,h:300,cg:true,m/cr=w:600,h:300)
Petoskey is our hometown! While we grew up in Northern Michigan, our journey in sustainable small-scale farming began at "Origins Hobby Farm" where we lived and raised our two kids in Southwest Michigan. After 20+ years, we sold Origins Hobby Farm when Jack's career took us on a venture. We are grateful to have experienced life in coastal Southern California and life in the lone star state near the Dallas Fort-Worth area.

With a seven-year hiatus from farming and land ownership, we've now laid down fresh roots back in our home town of Petoskey, Michigan with "Horton Bay Heritage Farm." This is our renewed commitment to learning, nurturing the land, cherishing our community, and sharing the abundant rewards of farmstead living.

For now, our “team” is a family affair. Jack works evenings and weekends after his day job, and I manage the farm full-time. Our days are brightened by our official greeter, Jax the Doberman, our emotional support nugget Bella the French Bulldog, and more barn cats than we can count — all equally committed to quality control and good company.
As the farm grows, we look forward to welcoming a small but mighty team to help us continue building the Farm together.
Welcome to the farm! ~Kathleen & Jack Nestell
Every farming practice leaves a mark, and at our Northern Michigan small-scale farm, we aim to go beyond sustainability. While terms like sustainable, regenerative, and ecological agriculture are often used interchangeably, they reflect distinct approaches with shared goals.
Sustainable agriculture focuses on meeting present needs without compromising the future, minimizing environmental impact while maintaining economic viability.
Regenerative agriculture goes further, actively restoring soil health, boosting biodiversity, and capturing carbon to combat climate change.
Ecological agriculture treats the farm as a living ecosystem, prioritizing natural processes, biodiversity, and resilience while reducing external inputs.
These approaches are not separate — they are deeply interconnected. We believe in combining these principles to farm in harmony with nature, our family, and our community.
To us, farmsteading is about more than growing food or raising animals. It is about cultivating a legacy of stewardship that reflects our values, our love for the land, and our commitment to thoughtful, life-giving practices.
People often ask whether Horton Bay Heritage Farm is organic. The honest answer is that we farm using organic practices, but we are not certified organic.
For us, this way of farming is not about a label. It is about growing clean, nourishing food for our own family and for our community, while caring for the long-term health of the soil, water, plants, animals, pollinators and land around us.
We are not currently pursuing organic certification because of the cost, paperwork and administrative burden it would add to a small family farm — costs that would ultimately be reflected in the price of our farm goods. Instead, we focus our energy on the daily work of farming with transparency, care and common sense.
We avoid synthetic pesticides and herbicides, use organic-approved products and natural growing methods when intervention is needed, build soil health through compost, mulch, cover crops and natural fertility, and welcome honest conversations about how we grow. Our farm has an open-door spirit, and we are happy to share our practices with customers who want to know more about where their food, flowers and plants come from.
We are deeply committed to the future of this farm, Bay Township and the communities of Petoskey, Charlevoix and Boyne City that surround us. By honoring the past and working thoughtfully in the present, we utilize sustainable farming practices not just for today, but for generations to come.
The Farmer’s Notebook offers seasonal updates, behind-the-scenes farm life, and insights into how we grow and raise food with care.
Subscribe to get seasonal updates, farm happenings and community opportunities!
Copyright © 2026 Horton Bay Heritage Farm - All Rights Reserved.
Horton Bay Heritage Farm Petoskey, Michigan - 231-753-8515
Powered by GoDaddy Website Builder
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.